Homemade Pistachio Butter

Homemade pistachio butterOne of my favorite things about having a Vitamix is getting to make my own nut butters from scratch.  Not only do I always have a batch of homemade peanut butter in the refrigerator (ingredients: peanuts and a pinch of salt), I can also make some nut butters that aren’t always available in jars.

Recently I’ve fallen hard for pistachio butter.  Pistachios have been one of my favorite nuts for years now.  When I’m eating a handful of pistachios they usually involve a little more time on task with opening the shells and using half of the shell to pry open those that simply won’t budge, but that’s part of the fun.  Obviously for the purposes of nut butter, I use shelled pistachios for convenience and time’s sake.

With its yellowy brown shade, I can see why pistachio butter hasn’t become a major contender in the looks department.  It’s not the prettiest nut butter you’ve ever seen in your life, but the taste more than makes up for it.  It’s great anywhere that you would use peanut butter (like with apple slices for a snack), but it brings a buttery undertone that is all its own.

Homemade pistachio butterWhenever I make nut butters, I always make sure to buy at least two cups of dry roasted and unsalted nuts, so that once they start grinding, they don’t get too low to be hit by the blade.  (I highly recommend getting unsalted, so that you can salt to taste.  With pistachio butter, I don’t think any salt is necessary.)

In a high-speed blender, it takes a minute, tops, to make.  I turn the blender to a medium speed and just use the tamper to further press the nuts into the blade as needed along the sides until the butter is moving easily.  (I know there are people who swear by using their food processor for nut butters, but my simple food processor really isn’t up to the task.  Plus, in the blender it’s so fast.)

Since nut butter likes to stick to the sides, once I’ve removed all that I can from the canister, I make a smoothie or peanut sauce in the blender jar, so that any remaining butter sticking to the sides or underneath the blade is loosened and used.

Homemade pistachio butterFor Sunday breakfast yesterday, I used the pistachio butter as a topping for Sinfully Wholesome Waffles from Isa Does It.  I slathered pistachio butter on top of the hearty waffles along with banana slices and a drizzling of maple syrup.  (For more from Isa Does It, I have reviews here and here.)

After David and I each had a couple, I put the remaining waffles into the freezer, separated by parchment paper, so that I can pop them straight into the toaster for easy breakfasts throughout the week.  It’s always such a treat to have homemade waffles ready at a moment’s notice!  Add that to the list of 5 minute breakfasts!

Homemade pistachio butter

What is your favorite nut butter?

Disclaimer: There are affiliate links in this post.


    • says

      I get them from Trader Joe’s. I think a bag of unshelled, unsalted pistachios is about $5.99. Then I use the entire bag for nut butter.

    • says

      I so know the feeling! I wanted one for YEARS before I finally bought one. I ended up getting a refurbished one from their website and saving a hundred bucks. It still has a long warranty and has worked great. I know others who have had good luck finding them for a good price at Costco & on QVC.

      I daresay waffles are even better straight from the toaster. They reach maximum crispiness that way!

    • says

      It’s funny how some nuts we only think of for certain uses, while others we turn to more often for things like nut butter. You’ll have to give it a whirl sometime, Laura! I think you’d like it!

    • says

      Well, obviously my pick would be to have you over for breakfast. Do you take coffee, tea, or neither? :)

      Isn’t that Curried Peanut Sauce bowl so good? Even though I want to make lots of new recipes from Isa Does It, that’s one I’ve made multiple times.

  1. says

    Pistachio butter? Shut the front door! I need some of that in my life. My favourite off-kilter butter is pumpkin seed – always using the stuff in sandwiches (or pretty much anywhere else I can think of!)

    • says

      I’ve never made pumpkin seed butter! In fact, unless it’s Halloween or a specific recipe calls for them, I always forget about pumpkin seeds. After I run out of pistachio butter, I’ll have to pick up a bag of pumpkin seeds. Thanks for the heads-up!

  2. says

    so yums!!! Last year for NoRooz, I got some really good medjool dates and stuffed them with crunchy pistachio butter and then topped them with shredded coconut. SO GOOD! I’m thinking of doing it again this year. I’m in the midst of norooz menu planning!! :) xo

    • says

      Wow, that sounds fabulous! For a while I was really into stuffing dates with coconut butter. I know I’d love them with pistachio butter and coconut on top. I’ll have to try that!

      I can’t wait to hear all of your Norooz highlights!!!

    • says

      Yes, get on it! Your Vitamix was BUILT for doing jobs like this. There’s no reason to have one and not put it to good use. Let me know how it goes! :)

  3. Heather says

    Love all nut butters, I have never had pistachio butter but pistachios are my favorite nut so I am sure I would love this!

  4. says

    Hi that looks amazing! Pistachio butter on waffles sounds awesome! ! Would be even cooler with pistachio ice cream! What waffle maker do you use by the way? Those waffles look better than most :) thanks and have a great day 😀

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>